Paneer ka Pakoda: Adulterating through Profit, Purity, and Health Perils

So the paneer is now a profitable food, and scaremongering is a new ritual Indians are following on their socials. Seems to be a pleasant way of telling everyone to stop eating, drinking, and even breathing. Basically, we all just need to stop living.

 

So it is good to have people like Krish Ashok who try to bring in the science of cooking with the art of sieving information from the crepes and scares.

 

The Indian paneer market is a massive, growing industry, with an estimated value of INR 648.05 billion in 2024 and a projected growth to over INR 2 trillion by 2033. This surge is fueled by a rising vegetarian population, urbanization, and the increasing demand for convenient, packaged foods. However, this immense profitability has created a darker, parallel market driven by adulteration and food fraud. The reality is a complex mix of legitimate, high-quality production and a widespread, dangerous practice of selling "fake" paneer.

 

The Truth About Paneer Adulteration

 

The scaremongering around paneer isn't an exaggeration; it's a reflection of a real and serious public health threat. Food safety investigations have revealed alarming statistics, with reports from cities like Noida and Greater Noida showing that a significant percentage of paneer samples, in some cases as high as 83%, failed quality standards, and nearly 40% were deemed unsafe for consumption. This isn't just a matter of poor quality; it's a matter of harmful substances being used to cut costs and increase profits.

 

What is a fake paneer? It's not a dairy product at all. It's often made from ingredients like:

 

Synthetic Milk: A dangerous concoction of detergents, caustic soda, urea, and water.

 

Starch and Flour: Used to increase weight and volume, significantly diluting the nutritional value.

 

Non-Dairy Fats and Oils: Used to mimic the creamy texture but often containing harmful trans fats.

 

Formalin: A highly toxic chemical, sometimes used as a preservative to extend shelf life.

 

The consumption of these adulterated products poses severe health risks, including digestive disorders, kidney and liver damage, and an increased risk of cancer from long-term exposure to carcinogens like formalin.

 

The Economic Angle: Why Adulteration Thrives

 

The primary driver behind this food fraud is, quite simply, profit. The cost of producing authentic paneer from fresh milk is high, with milk prices fluctuating and the process itself being labor and resource-intensive. Adulterating paneer allows illicit manufacturers to bypass these costs, producing a product that looks and feels like the real thing but is sold at a much higher margin.

 

This poses a significant challenge for reputable dairy companies and cooperatives like Amul and Mother Dairy, which adhere to strict quality controls and FSSAI (Food Safety and Standards Authority of India) regulations. While their products are generally safe and of high quality, they must compete with the low prices of adulterated paneer in the market. This creates a difficult landscape where consumers, often unaware of the dangers, may opt for cheaper, unbranded alternatives.

 

Regulatory Efforts and Consumer Empowerment

 

The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has been proactive in addressing this issue. FSSAI has established specific standards for paneer, mandating a minimum fat content of 50% on a dry matter basis and a maximum moisture content of 70%. The use of any toxic additives is strictly prohibited. Authorities regularly conduct raids and inspections, seizing large quantities of adulterated products and initiating legal action against offenders, who can face significant fines and even imprisonment.

 

However, the sheer scale of the problem means that regulatory action alone isn't enough. Empowering consumers is crucial. Here's how individuals can protect themselves:

 

1.  Buy from trusted sources: Opt for packaged paneer from well-known and reputable brands with FSSAI certification. Avoid loose, unbranded paneer, especially during festive seasons when demand is high.

 

2.  Look for warning signs:

 

Texture: Authentic paneer is soft but firm and crumbles when pressed. Fake paneer may feel rubbery or stretchy.

 

Taste and Smell: Adulterated paneer can have a bitter or chemical aftertaste and an odd smell.

 

Heat Test: When heated, pure paneer softens and may release fat, while fake paneer can become tough or rubbery.

 

3.  Perform simple home tests: A common test for starch involves placing a drop of iodine solution on a piece of paneer. If the colour changes to a blue-black hue, it indicates the presence of starch.

 

The paneer industry is a microcosm of India's rapid economic growth, showcasing both the incredible potential for profit and the ethical and safety challenges that can arise. While the industry is thriving on the back of genuine demand, the battle against adulteration is far from over. By staying informed and demanding better, consumers can ensure that the paneer on their plate is a source of health and nutrition, not a hidden danger.

 

Paneer Pyaaza might not stay chutzpah anymore if we keep curdling all the fakes, will it?

 

Want to contribute such insightful articles? Connect with us on

contact@upshotbrandmedia.com or on call at +91 8962429492